Abstract. Calcium (Ca) may contribute to the preservation of soil organic carbon (SOC) in more ecosystems than previously thought. Here, we provide evidence that Ca is co-located with SOC compounds that are enriched in aromatic and phenolic groups, across different acidic soil types and locations with different ecosystem properties, differing in terms of climate, parent material, soil type, and vegetation. In turn, this co-localised fraction of Ca–SOC is removed through cation exchange, and the association is then only re-established during decomposition in the presence of Ca (Ca addition incubation). Thus, this highlights a causative link between decomposition and the co-location of Ca with a characteristic fraction of SOC. Decomposition increases the relative proportion of negatively charged functional groups, which can increase the propensity for the association between SOC and Ca; in turn, this association can inhibit dissolved organic carbon export or further decomposition. We propose that this mechanism could be driven by Ca hotspots at the microscale shifting local decomposition processes and thereby explaining the co-location of Ca with SOC of a specific composition across different acidic soil environments. Incorporating this biogeochemical process into Earth system models could improve our understanding, predictions, and management of carbon dynamics in soils, as well as accounting for their response to Ca-rich amendments.