Both policy-makers and agricultural economists place hope in result-based payment schemes for farmers, also in the realm of nitrate leaching to drinking water reserves. It is first shown that it is useful to refine this view, distinguishing between driver-, pressure- and state-related approaches. We then present four mitigation projects with different angles for financial transfers to farmers. Through interviews with project managers and additional document analysis it is determined that the trustworthiness of land managers, correct assumptions on causalities and hydrogeological areas of contribution, good group dynamics, fast hydrogeological responses and transaction costs are the factors determining which of the approaches, if any, is most effective. This should enable informed policy choices for projects where nitrate concentrations have to be reduced.