In many regions, nutritional claims regarding food protein quality rely solely on protein content, neglecting the digestible indispensable amino acid score (DIAAS), which is internationally recognized as a physiologically relevant measure of protein quality. DIAAS is preferably determined using in vivo methods, however, animal models raise time, cost, and ethical concerns that have restrained protein quality assessments of ingredients. Therefore, this study aimed to evaluate the protein quality of common animal- and plant-derived foods using the INFOGEST Quant protocol, a validated static in vitro method that mimics in vivo models. Nineteen foods were digested, and the absorbable and non-absorbable fractions were analyzed for total nitrogen, amino groups, and individual amino acids to determine total protein digestibility, individual amino acid digestibility, and DIAAS. Total amino acid-based digestibility exceeded 90% for all products except cooked potato (81.2%), soy flour (88.4%), raw pinto bean (61.8%), and egg white powder (76.3%). Cooked meat achieved a DIAAS above 100% using both the young-child and adult reference patterns, whereas casein, skim milk powder, and soy protein isolate exceeded 100% using the adult reference pattern. Some legumes reached a DIAAS of ≥75%, whereas cereals, nuts, and cooked potato mostly remained below this threshold, primarily because of their low lysine contents. The principal limiting amino acids in legumes were sulfur amino acids, leucine and valine, while raw pinto beans showed low DIAAR values for all amino acids. Overall, these findings highlight that protein concentration, amino acid profile and digestibility must be considered when evaluating dietary protein sources.